Review of Federal STD Prevention Efforts Estimates
Millions of Averted Infections and Billions Saved in Direct Medical Costs
Amsterdam, the Netherlands – New data show a heavy burden of
chlamydia in young women and men in the United States, particularly among
pregnant women attending publicly funded clinics and economically
disadvantaged youth, according to the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC). Other research found that federal sexually transmitted
disease (STD) prevention efforts have prevented millions of infections and
saved an estimated $5 billion in direct medical costs over the past 30 years.
These new data were presented at the 16th biennial meeting of the
International Society for Sexually Transmitted Diseases Research (ISSTDR),
July 10-13, in Amsterdam.
“STDs often have no symptoms and therefore frequently go unrecognized and
undiagnosed,” said Dr. John Douglas, director of CDC’s STD prevention
programs. “Stepping up screening and prevention efforts is critical to
ensuring that young people do not suffer the long-term effects of untreated
chlamydia, including infertility.”
Toll of chlamydia greatest among young women, but men also bear heavy
burden
In the first nationally representative study of chlamydia prevalence in
the general adult population (ages 14-39), CDC researchers found a chlamydia
prevalence of 2.2 percent and no significant differences between women and
men overall. Nearly 1 in 20 women between the ages of 14-19 (4.6 percent)
were infected – the highest proportion of any age group. Among men, 20- to
29-year-olds were most heavily affected, with a prevalence of 3.2 percent.
Prevalence was higher among blacks in all age groups, at 6.4 percent,
compared to 1.5 percent among whites. The findings were based on responses
from participants in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES)
from 1999 to 2002 (Abstract TP-078).
Two separate analyses of economically disadvantaged young adults (16-24)
enrolled in a national job training program found that roughly 1 in 10 were
infected with chlamydia. Analysis of test results from more than 106,000
young women from 1998 through 2004, nearly two-thirds of whom were black or
Hispanic, found that 10.9 percent were infected. Prevalence was highest among
16-year-old women at 13.3 percent (Abstract TP-065).
CDC’s evaluation of test results from more than 50,000 young men (63
percent of them black or Hispanic) in the same job training program from July
2003 to December 2004 represented the first widespread chlamydia screening
among men in the U.S. The results showed 8.2 percent were infected with
chlamydia, with the highest rate among 20- to 24-year-old men (8.8 percent).
Only 2.4 percent of men with chlamydia had reported symptoms, suggesting they
would have remained undiagnosed without the screening offered by this program
(Abstract TP-067).
Chlamydia infection high among pregnant women, particularly minority
women
In a separate study, researchers analyzed data on more than 86,000 women
ages 15-45 who were screened for chlamydia at publicly funded prenatal
clinics in 18 states 1. Test results were
positive for 5.8 percent, with the highest prevalence among 15- to
19-year-olds (9.7 percent). Prevalence among black women (11.1 percent) was
nearly four times that of white (3.9 percent) and Hispanic (3.8 percent)
women. Because chlamydia can have serious consequences for newborns,
including pneumonia and conjunctivitis, study authors recommend continued
emphasis on prenatal chlamydia screening (Abstract TP-066).
In 2003, 877,478 cases of chlamydia were reported in the United States,
making it the nation’s most commonly reported STD. Chlamydia is easily cured
with antibiotics but is often undiagnosed because of its lack of symptoms.
Besides infertility, the disease can cause other serious health problems in
women: pelvic inflammatory disease, ectopic pregnancy, and chronic pelvic
pain. CDC recommends the delay of sexual initiation among teens as the only
100 percent effective method of STD prevention, and annual chlamydia
screening for all sexually active women under age 25.
Federal prevention efforts avert millions of STD infections – and save
billions of dollars in medical expenses
Two other CDC studies presented at the 16th ISSTDR meeting found that
federal STD prevention efforts are having a dramatic impact in reducing
disease and associated health costs.
The first study examined the impact of federal STD prevention efforts over
the past 33 years, estimating that approximately 32 million cases of
gonorrhea were averted from 1971 to 2003 as a result of such efforts.
Researchers’ estimates were based on historical records of federal funding to
state and local health departments for STD prevention and previously
published research about the impact of the funding on gonorrhea rates at the
state level. The study demonstrated that STD prevention programs paid for
themselves. Savings realized by preventing gonorrhea exceeded the STD
prevention program expenditures by $1.4 billion during the 33-year period
(Abstract MP-194).
In the second analysis, researchers estimated that reductions in annual
incidence of gonorrhea and syphilis from 1990 to 2003 saved $5 billion in
direct medical costs. This estimate was based on reported cases of the two
diseases in the United States, coupled with published estimates of direct
medical costs per STD case. Authors calculated that the total direct medical
cost of gonorrhea and syphilis was $3.8 billion over the 14-year period,
compared to $8.9 billion if STD rates had remained at their 1990 levels
(Abstract MP-193). Because gonorrhea and syphilis infection are known to
increase the risk of HIV transmission, a significant portion of the total
savings ($3.9 billion) reflected HIV infections that were averted due to
reduced gonorrhea and syphilis rates.
“STD prevention efforts are increasingly shown to be effective and
economically sound strategies for improving the nation’s health,” said CDC’s
Dr. Douglas. “Current challenges demand that we remain vigilant and continue
working to make sure that effective prevention programs are available in
every community and to all who need them.”
For more information about CDC HIV and STD prevention efforts, visit:
http://www.cdc.gov/nchstp/od/nchstp.html.
_________
1 The 18 states are Arkansas, Delaware,
Florida, Illinois, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi,
Nebraska, New Jersey, New Mexico, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Oregon, South
Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia